Beyond the Shock Machine
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/radioeye/stories/2008/2358103.htm
Interviews with the participants in Milgram's experiment.
I learned more from this than I have from anything I've heard thus far. College psych summaries of Milgram's experiment leave out the details of an intricately (some may say deviously) designed scenario. Who would have known that the actor hired for the role of experimenter was rehearsed for half a year before the experiment took place?
This was my chance to sit in the participant's chair and face the details of their experience. For anyone who has wondered, "Couldn't the participants opt to leave?" we learn the answer is an absolute NO. Any request to exit the experiment is met, two or three or a google times, with an absolutist "The experiment MUST go ON!" Intimidation is used handily and freely.
At some point you start to see the participant being played for a fool. And you wonder... when are they going to cut this person a break?
One of the participants suggests that Milgram had a perverse side to him, that he got the sense Milgram pushed and pressed people until he could find something dark in their nature -- and was satisfied when he did. Solid results are the goal of an experimenter, sure, but you wonder if this participant might be on to something.
Then there's the bits where you hear the participants' thought processes during the experiment. This piece is the most important one, and the one that has been absent in the retellings of this famous experiment. Dr. X has a theory about why the people did what they did, and so does Dr. Y... and so does Dr. Milgram himself. But if we really want to know what was going on people's heads at the time, it makes sense to ask them.
Done rambling.
Interviews with the participants in Milgram's experiment.
I learned more from this than I have from anything I've heard thus far. College psych summaries of Milgram's experiment leave out the details of an intricately (some may say deviously) designed scenario. Who would have known that the actor hired for the role of experimenter was rehearsed for half a year before the experiment took place?
This was my chance to sit in the participant's chair and face the details of their experience. For anyone who has wondered, "Couldn't the participants opt to leave?" we learn the answer is an absolute NO. Any request to exit the experiment is met, two or three or a google times, with an absolutist "The experiment MUST go ON!" Intimidation is used handily and freely.
At some point you start to see the participant being played for a fool. And you wonder... when are they going to cut this person a break?
One of the participants suggests that Milgram had a perverse side to him, that he got the sense Milgram pushed and pressed people until he could find something dark in their nature -- and was satisfied when he did. Solid results are the goal of an experimenter, sure, but you wonder if this participant might be on to something.
Then there's the bits where you hear the participants' thought processes during the experiment. This piece is the most important one, and the one that has been absent in the retellings of this famous experiment. Dr. X has a theory about why the people did what they did, and so does Dr. Y... and so does Dr. Milgram himself. But if we really want to know what was going on people's heads at the time, it makes sense to ask them.
Done rambling.